PIE MENU PORT CARLING

GBC ⓥ

Oven-baked PIE dough with garlic butter, mozzarella, parmesan, served with house-made garlic aioli.

$10.25   Add crispy bacon + $3.00

FOUR CHEESE SPINACH & ARTICHOKE DIP ⓥ

Great for sharing, served with olive oil pizza crust slices. 
$14.95

NOT JUST WARM OLIVES ⓥ

Black and green olives, roasted red peppers, artichokes, smoked halloumi, served with crostini.

$11.95 

FLAVOURS OF PIE PLATTER

Selection of andouille sausage, smoked halloumi, roasted red peppers, cherry tomato confit, green olive tapenade, served with crostini.

$19.50

WOOD FIRED CHICKEN WINGS

Tossed in our honey lemon rosemary sauce, served with a side of olives & choice of house-made dip. 

1 lb – $17.00             2lb – $28.50

 

MEATBALL SLIDERS

House-made meatballs on toasted ciabatta, tomato sauce, mozzarella & crispy bacon. 

$14.50

GARDEN SALAD ⓥ

Crisp greens with cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, red peppers & red wine vinaigrette. 

$10.50

CAPRESE SALAD ⓥ

Roma & cherry tomatoes, fior di latte, fresh basil & balsamic reduction. 

$13.00

CAESAR SALAD

Romaine, crispy bacon, herbed croutons, parmesan, fresh lemon & creamy caesar dressing. 

$12.50

SPINACH & ARUGULA SALAD

Sliced pear, toasted walnuts, crumbled blue cheese & balsamic vinaigrette.

$13.00

MAC & CHEESE ⓥ

Béchamel sauce, mozzarella, parmesan & breadcrumbs.

$16.95   Add crispy bacon + $3.00

STUFFED RAVIOLI MEDALLIONS ⓥ

Ricotta, parmesan & fontina stuffed ravioli, sautéed in brown butter with basil pesto. 

$19.75

BAKED RIGATONI

Rose sauce, andouille sausage, red onion, cherry tomato confit & mozzarella. 

$20.50 

BAKED SPICY PENNE ⓢ

Tomato sauce, spicy sausage, crispy bacon & mozzarella. 

$19.75 

ADD DIP: Garlic aioli, spicy aioli, pesto aioli 

$1.25 each

JUST CHEESE ⓥ

Tomato sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.

$11.75

QUEEN PIE ⓥ

Tomato sauce, fior di latte, fresh basil & house-infused olive oil. 

$14.75

PEPPERONI

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni & fresh basil.

$14.75

HIND LEG

Tomato sauce, fior di latte, finished with crisp arugula, prosciutto & 

house-infused olive oil.

$19.50

SWEET & SPICY ⓢ

Tomato sauce, goat cheese, spicy calabrese salami, caramelized onion & fresh basil.

$19.25

MUSKOKA PIE

Tomato sauce, fior di latte, pepperoni, caramelized onion, roasted mushrooms & fresh basil.

$19.25

PORKY PIE

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, double smoked bacon, spicy sausage, finished with prosciutto & fresh basil.

$19.95

HEDGE HOG ⓢ

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, hot pepper puree, pepperoni, spicy sausage, spicy calabrese salami, finished with garlic aioli drizzle.

$19.95

CLUCK NORRIS PIE

Tomato sauce, goat cheese, roasted chicken breast, cherry tomato confit, basil pesto, finished with crisp arugula & balsamic reduction.

$20.50

VEGGILANTE PIE ⓥ

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, mushrooms, spinach, roasted garlic & basil pesto.

$18.50

BEAUTY PIE

Tomato sauce, goat cheese, black and green olives, roasted red 

peppers & fresh basil. 

$17.50

MASI CAPRESE

Tomato sauce, finished with crisp arugula, fior di latte, cherry tomato confit, parmesan & balsamic reduction.  

$19.75

ST. LUCIA

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, double smoked bacon, pineapple, toasted coconut & fresh basil.

$18.00

MYSTIC NORTH

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, andouille sausage, roasted mushrooms, black olives, red onion & fresh basil.

$20.95

DOUBLE SMOKED FUN GUY

Béchamel sauce, mozzarella, roasted mushrooms, spinach,

double smoked bacon & parmesan. 

$19.50

ULTIMATE CANADIAN

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, fior di latte, double smoked bacon, crispy bacon & maple chili glaze.

$20.95

STINKY PIE ⓥ

Basil pesto, blue cheese, sliced pear, sweet, caramelized onion, toasted walnuts & balsamic reduction. 

$19.25

TSUNAMI ⓢ

Béchamel sauce, hot pepper puree, fior di latte, spinach, roasted garlic, roasted chicken breast, parmesan & fresh basil. 

$20.95  Add crispy bacon + $3.00 

LOADED BAKED POTATO

Béchamel sauce, mozzarella, roasted potato, crispy bacon, finished with rosemary sour cream drizzle & fresh chives. 

$18.95

YOU HAD ME AT HALLOUMI ⓥ

Olive oil, smoked halloumi, black & green olives, red onion, artichokes, roasted red peppers & fresh basil.  

$20.50 

ADD DIP: Garlic aioli, spicy aioli, pesto aioli 

$1.25 each

HOT STOVE BUTTER TART

Don’s signature flakey pastry, filled with a silky buttery center. 

$9.95 Add ice cream + $2.50 

BROWNIE SKILLET

Warm double chocolate, doubly chewy brownie, topped with French vanilla ice cream. 

$9.95

SEASON’S PEAK PIE

Don’s personal dessert pie, with orchard fresh fruit filling, served warm. 

Ask your server about our seasonal offerings. 

$9.95 Add ice cream + $2.50 

FRENCH VANILLA ICE CREAM

Comes with 3 scoops. 

$6.50 

 

ⓥ Vegetarian

ⓢ Spicy

 

THE PINK WHITLEY NEIL

 1.5oz Whitley Neill Dry gin, aromatic tonic, citrus & mint garnish. 

$10.50 

RHUBARB G&T

1.5oz Whitley Neill Rhubarb & Ginger gin, traditional tonic, citrus & rosemary garnish. 

$10.50 

CAESAR

1oz vodka, clamato juice, hot sauce, worcestershire & our house twist. 

$9.50 

CAESAR NOIR

 1.5oz tequila blanco, clamato juice, hot sauce, worcestershire & noir spice blend. 

$11.50 

MUSKOKA MULE

1oz vodka, basil, cranberries, ginger beer. 

$10.00 

NEGRONI

 1oz campari, 1/2oz blood orange gin, 1/2oz sweet vermouth, orange twist. 

$9.50 

MOJITO

1oz white rum, mint, lime, simple syrup, topped with soda. 

$9.50 

PIE HARD LEMONADE

1/2oz raspberry vodka, 1/2oz peach schnapps, lemonade, soda, fresh raspberries. 

$9.00

BEST OF BOTH WORLDS

1oz blood orange gin, 6oz blanche de chambly, basil, simple syrup, citrus garnish.

$10.00

KRYPTONITE

1oz white rum, 1 oz blue curacao, pineapple & orange juice. 

$9.50 

WHITE SANGRIA

 1/2oz triple sec, 3oz white wine, citrus juices, finished with prosecco & fresh fruit, 1oz prosecco.

Glass – $9.00 1L – $23.00

RED SANGRIA

 1/2oz cherry brandy, 3oz red wine, citrus juices, gingerale & fresh fruit. 

Glass – $9.00 1L – $23.00

APEROL SPRITZ

2oz aperol, 3oz Masi prosecco, twist of orange. 

$9.50 

GIN-SECCO

 1oz Rhubarb & Ginger gin, 1/2oz sweet vermouth, prosecco, rosemary, 3oz prosecco

$9.50 

SLEEMAN ORIGINAL

 Pint – $8.00

STEAM WHISTLE

 Pint – $8.00

SLEEMAN CLEAR

 Pint– $7.50 

LOST CRAFT REVIVAL

 Pint – $7.50 

SAPPORO

 Pint – $8.50 

FLYING MONKEYS -ROTATIONAL

Pint – $8.50

BLANCHE DE CHAMBLY

 Pint – $8.50 

LOST CRAFT IPA (ROTATIONAL)

 Pint – $8.00

ELMVALE ALE

Pint – $7.00 Barrie & Port Carling Only 

FLYING MONKEYS JUICY ASS

 Pint – $8.50 Barrie & Port Carling Only 

STELLA

 330ML – $5.75 

Dejado Tequila Soda

 473ML – $7.00

CORONA

 330ML – $5.75 

Pabst Blue Ribbon

 355ML – $4.75 

LAKE OF BAYS RED ALE

 473ML – $7.00

SWAY RASPBERRY VODKA SODA

 355ML – $6.00

Lost Craft Dry Rose Cider

 473ML – $7.00

STEIGEL RADLER

 500ML – $7.00

SLEEMAN CLEAR PEACH

 355ML – $5.50 

PROSECCO MASI – ITALY

Try it with: You Had Me At Halloumi 

6oz – $10.50 

9oz- $13.50 

BTL – $35.00

PINOT GRIGIO RONCO DE GELSO – ITALY

Try it with: Caprese Salad 

BTL – $62.00

SAUVIGNON BLANC CONO SUR TOCORNAL – CHILE

Try it with: Veggilante Pie 

6oz – $7.50 

9oz – $10.50 

TREBBIANO D’ABRUZZO MASCARELLI – ITALY

Try it with: Stuffed Ravioli Medallions 

BTL – $53.00

PINOT GRIGIO MASI – ITALY

Try it with: Going Back To Cali Pie 

6oz –$9.50 

9oz- $12.50 

BTL –$31.25 

SAUVIGNON BLANC CROWDED HOUSE - NEW ZEALAND

Try it with: Cluck Norris Pie 

BTL – $68.00

CHARDONNAY WENTE – CALIFORNIA

Try it with: Spinach & Arugula Salad 

6oz –$11.00

9oz- $14.00

BTL –$35.00

CABERNET/ MERLOT BLEND CONO SUR – CHILE

Try it with: Baked Spicy Penne 

6oz – $7.50 

9oz – $10.50 

VALPOLICELLA MASI BONACOSTA – ITALY

Try it with: Not Just Warm Olives 

6oz- $9.50 

9oz- $12.50 

BTL – $31.25 

MALBEC MASI – ARGENTINA

Try it with: Flavours of Pie Platter 

6oz- $9.00 

9oz- $12.00 

BTL – $30.00 

CAMPOFIORIN MASI RIPASSO – ITALY

Try it with: Baked Rigatoni 

BTL – $49.00

MERLOT MASI MODELLO – ITALY 

Try it with: Cluck Norris Pie 

6oz- $9.00

9oz- $12.00 

BTL – $30.00

MALBEC ANDELUNA – ARGENTINA 

Try it with: Mystic North 

BTL – $58.00 

MONTEPULCIANO D’ABRUZZO  Mascarelli - ITALY 

Try it with: Tsunami Pie 

BTL – $57.00

BIFERNO ROSSO RISERVA  TOMBACCO – ITALY 

Try it with: Baked Rigatoni 

BTL – $49.00

CABERNET SAUVIGNON WENTE – CALIFORNIA 

Try it with: Double Smoked Fun Guy 

6oz- $11.00

9oz- $14.00

BTL – $35.00

 IT’S PARTY TIME AT PIE! 

PIE parties are unlimited family style eating designed for groups of 8 or more guests. Providing your guests are still eating, we can continue to bring out more food! PIE parties allow everyone to eat at the same time and a great way to try a variety of our menu items. 

 PIE PARTY 

Includes the following menu items: 

Warm olives

– An assortment of select pizzas (Just cheese, queen, pepperoni, hedgehog, sweet & spicy, beauty, Muskoka, double smoked fun guy) 

$19.50/ per person 

 PIE & SALAD PARTY 

 Includes the following menu items: 

– Warm olives

– Caesar salad

– Garden salad

– An assortment of select pizzas (Just cheese, queen, pepperoni, hedgehog, sweet & spicy, beauty, Muskoka, double smoked fun guy) 

$22.00/ per person 

ULTIMATE PIE PARTY

 Includes the following menu items: 

– Warm olives

 – Mac & cheese

 – An assortment of all wood fired pizzas on the menu

$22.50/ per person 

ULTIMATE PIE & SALAD PARTY

 Includes the following menu items: 

– Warm olives

– Mac & cheese

– Caesar salad

– Garden salad 

– An assortment of all wood fired pizzas on the menu 

$25.00/ per person 

KIDS PARTY

 $10/child for kids aged 10 years or younger with any of the above packages. 

 ADDITIONAL OPTIONS 

Add wings – $15.00/per pound

Add bottomless soft drinks – $3.00/per person

Add child’s drink – $1.50/per child

Please note that we do not allow substitutions to the appetizer selection or pizza selection of our party packages. Additional menu items may be added at regular menu price.